Floating hardwood flooring
You have a concrete subfloor. When considering the choice of floating your hardwood floor or directly gluing it down to the concrete subfloor, the following list of pros and cons should help you make the right choice.
The first thing you should do however is check with your strata if you have one. Quite often there are rules in place that govern the method of hardwood flooring installation.

Lets start with  the floating floor method of installation. 

The term 'floating hardwood floor' refers to the method of installation.  A floating floor rests on underlay and is not fixed to the substrate or subfloor. Essentially, gravity holds the floor down.

Floating floors
1. Less expensive than the glue down alternative due to less installation time and minimal adhesive cost.

2. Easier to install especially for the 'do-it-yourselfer'

3. Quieter for your neighbours below. The two air pockets between the flooring and underlay and between the underlay and the concrete break down sound transference better than when the floor is glued down.

4. A finished floating hardwood deflects or 'gives' sightly when walked on. This makes living on the floor easier on your legs and back.  Don't worry, the movement in the floor is to be expected because the floor rests on a soft underlay however the amount of deflection must not be excessive. 1/8" is acceptable. Your concrete subfloor should be leveled properly by your flooring contractor.   You should have no sudden drops or ridges in the concrete before you begin installation. Inadequate or poor leveling will leave excessive soft spots which can cause movement in the floor that may lead to breakdown later on.

5. Soundbarrier. There are many sound-rated underlays on the market, each with their own pros and cons.
Look for the IIC rating on the product (Impact Isolation Class). This rating indicates the amount of sound transference through the concrete subfloor to the space below in a test setting.  The higher the IIC number the less sound transference.  Various products on the market offer an IIC of between 60 and 73 and are priced accordingly.  The best value, in my opinion, is about 70.  Most sound rated underlays should cost you less than $1 per square foot.

Glue down hardwood flooring
Glue down floors
1. With this method of installation, the finished floor feels stronger and more solid underfoot. This is because the floor design doesn't allow for movement or slight deflection. 

2. Noise. Imagine the sound of a foot step on a glue down floor to be a 'dull thud' as opposed to a brighter 'clack' sound that comes with the floating floor design. The sound of the floor is generally quieter to live with because less noise is reflected back into the room you are in.

3. Expense. Glue down floors are more labour-intensive to install and the adhesive alone will add $1 plus to your cost.  If a sound barrier is required, then it will need to be glued to the concrete first, adding yet another $1plus per square foot for the adhesive PLUS labour to install.  You can see how the cost quickly adds up.

4. Removing a glue down floor is a tough job. The adhesive is very strong and designed not to let go.

5. Gluing hardwood to a concrete slab on grade requires a special moisture barrier (the grey product to the left of the glue bed in the picture). This will add another $1 plus labour to install, whereas a moisture barrier for floating floors is no more that  $.10  per square foot.

So that covers the basic pros and cons to consider when choosing a floating versus glue-down hardwood floor.

I'd be interested in hearing what your experiences have been with installations.  What were the biggest challenges you ran into?

 


Comments

08/28/2012 12:51am

Great blog post, however only a few of the points were actually treated really good,I definitely enjoyed what you had to say. Keep heading because you undoubtedly bring a new voice to this subject.

Reply
09/12/2012 4:04am

I am happy to find this content very helpful and informative for me, as it contains lot of accurate detailing about the topic, which I was searching for. Thanks a lot and good luck.

Reply
Chris
09/12/2012 11:55pm

Thanks for the comment. I'm glad you found the blog content useful.

Reply
Angela
07/22/2013 12:25pm

Hi Chris - Thanks for this post. Very helpful. I'm about to have the existing parquet hardwood floors in my 1960's condo replaced. With it being a condo, I have concrete subfloors, and I've been given different recommendations by different contractors regarding glued vs. floating floor installation. One suggested that the new floor be installed as a floating floor to save on cost and to visually help camouflage any unevenness in the floor. The other suggested that the new floor be glued down, as is the existing floor that's to be replaced. He said that floating floors feel less stable when you walk on them if the concrete subfloor isn't 100% perfectly level, and he said that, as a result, the more stable, glued down floor will add more value to the home, whereas a floating floor would be less valuable. I'm really torn as to which way to go based on this information. Any thoughts on these recommendations beyond what you've already written in your blog post? Thanks!

Reply
11/18/2013 11:03pm

After a long time I got something fresh and quality content on related topic. I searched a lot for the related material but got almost replica work. Keep it up! It is really very informative.

Reply
Barbara DeMaio
01/21/2014 4:22pm

I appreciate your straightforward pros and cons of floating vs. glue-down floors -- it is just what we were looking for to help us make a decision. However, the one unanswered question we have is, is one better than the other for moisture control. Our concrete slab is in Florida where moisture can be a problem and we are wondering if one method is preferable over the other in that regard. Thanks so much.

Reply



Leave a Reply

    Author

    My name is Chris Maskell. I've been in the hardwood flooring industry for 19 years in many different rolls, everything from sales to installation. This blog is meant as an insight into some of the problems we face in the world of hardwood flooring. Hopefully the topics will help you with your hardwood flooring experience. Feel free to comment or ask questions....

    Archives

    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012

    Categories

    All
    Hardwood Flooring
    Staining Hardwood